Best Material for Raised Garden Beds (Make Them Last!)


If you want to build your own raised garden bed, the first thing to do is choose a building material.  There are lots of possibilities – some are cheap and easy to find, while others are more expensive but will last a long time.

So, what material is best for raised garden beds?  The best materials for raised garden beds are stone, plastic such as HDPE, and durable wood, such as cypress, cedar, and redwood.  These materials will stand up well against damage caused by exposure to water, soil, and insects.

Of course, there are other materials you can use for building a raised garden bed, such as metal.  Durability is one consideration, but you also need to think about the cost, safety, and difficulty of working with the material you choose.

Let’s take a closer look at the materials you can use for raised garden beds.  I’ll also give some recommendations on the scenarios where each material works best.

Best Material for Raised Garden Beds

The best materials to use for raised garden beds are:

  • Stone (I’ll include bricks, pavers, concrete, and so forth in this category)
  • Plastic (the best option is a durable and safe recycled plastic, such as HDPE)
  • Wood (Redwood is one of the most durable, followed by cedar, and then cypress.  Oak and pine will not last long when exposed to water, soil, and insects.)
raised bed
Wood is a common material for raised beds, but you have other options, including stone, plastic, and metal.

You can also use metal for raised garden beds, but it can be dangerous if sharp, and iron or steel are prone to rust.  The material you decide to use will depend on where you live, how much you want to spend, and how long you want the raised bed to last.

Let’s start off by looking at the pros and cons of using stone for your raised beds.

Stone

Stone is one of the most durable materials you can use for building a raised bed.  Why do you think some castles, made of stone and built hundreds of years ago, are still standing?

I’ll include bricks, pavers, cinder blocks, and concrete in this category, along with ordinary rocks you would find in your backyard.  There are several benefits to using this material for building raised garden beds.

Pros of Stone

  • Stone is extremely durable.  There is no chance of insects chewing through it, and it will take many years for water and wind to damage it enough to wear it down even slightly.
  • Stone is widely available and easy to find.  You can get rocks for free from your backyard, or from a neighbor.  You might even be able to pick them up from a construction site (ask the foreman first!)  Bricks, pavers, cinder blocks, and concrete are all easy to find at garden centers, including Home Depot and Lowe’s.
  • Stone absorbs lots of heat, so it can warm up quickly in the sun.  This can be helpful if you need to warm up the soil early in the season when the sun is out, but temperatures are still low.

Although sturdy and widely available, stone does have its drawbacks as well.

brick raised beds
A raised bed made out of stone, bricks, or concrete will last a long time, so you won’t have to worry about replacing them.

Cons of Stone

  • Stone is heavy, and much more difficult to work with than wood or plastic.  Once you build a raised bed out of stone, it will not be easy to move!  Even worse, you can easily injure yourself on a DIY project when moving heavy stones.
  • A tall raised garden bed made of stone can be unstable.  You may need to use cement (you can also hire a mason) to hold it all together, making the project more expensive or time-consuming.
  • Stone can be expensive if you need to buy it at retail prices from a garden center or a landscaping supply company.
  • If you live in a hot climate, stone may absorb too much heat and make the soil in your raised bed too hot for some plants.
  • Cinder blocks may contain fly ash, a by-product of burning coal.  As such, it may contain heavy metals or other environmental hazards.  According to the University of Maryland Extension, you can seal cinder blocks with a polymer paint to avoid this hazard. 

Of course, if you are worried about toxicity from cinder blocks, you can choose to use another type of stone instead.

When to Use Stone

Stone is a great building material for raised beds in the following situations:

Cold Climate

Stone is a good choice if you live in a cold climate with a short growing season.  A raised bed made of stone will warm up the soil it contains.

The stones will transfer heat to the soil in the raised garden bed, which will heat up faster than the soil in the ground.  This will let you plant outside earlier in the season.

It will also let your plants survive later in the fall, which is helpful in cold climates.  Having warmer soil and a longer growing season is especially important for warm-weather crops, such as tomatoes, peppers, and cucumbers.

High Humidity

Stone is also a good alternative to wood in areas with high humidity (such as Florida).  In these areas, most untreated wood will rot quickly if exposed to water, soil, and insects.

If you live in Florida or other warm climates, be careful about the heat retained by stone.  Plants that are sensitive to heat may not do well on hot days if you put them in a raised bed made of stone.

Stony Yard

If there are lots of rocks in your yard (or in a neighbor’s yard), then you have the perfect source of stone for building your raised beds!  Just be sure to get help so that you don’t get hurt moving the stones.

Plastic

If stone is too heavy for your purposes, then consider using plastic instead.  Plastic is one of the lightest building materials you can use for a raised garden bed.  In fact, there are several additional benefits to using plastic.

Pros of Plastic

  • Plastic is light, compared to stone, wood, and metal.  If you ever decide to move or disassemble your raised bed, it will be much easier if you build with plastic.  You might even be able to disassemble a plastic raised bed and take it with you when you move to a new home!
  • Plastic is rot resistant, and will hold up well against water, soil, and insects.  This makes it a great alternative to wood if you want long-lasting raised beds that won’t rot like wood.
  • Plastic can be found in many colors.  You can choose a lighter color (such as white or tan) to absorb less sunlight and heat.  On the other hand, you can choose a darker color (such as black or dark grey) to absorb more sunlight and heat to keep the soil warmer.
  • Plastic is widely available and easy to find.  There are many raised garden bed kits to choose from, such as these from Gardener’s Supply Company.    You can also buy plastic “boards”, made of HDPE (high density polyethylene) or other recycled materials.  Use these boards, cut them to size, and build your own custom raised bed with any dimensions you want.  For example, you can find these plastic boards at Menard’s.
plastic planks
Lassen Trail Crew members prepare load of the recycled lumber for helicopter transportation into the Bumpass Hell Basin.

Cons of Plastic

Although there are many advantages to using plastic for raised beds, there are some disadvantages as well.

  • Some plastic will wear down and crack over time due to sun exposure.
  • Thin plastic may not hold up well against the weight of wet soil, which could lead to cracking.

Of course, you can always choose a thicker board size if you are worried about the weight of the soil.

When to Use Plastic

Plastic is great for building raised beds in the following situations:

High Humidity

Plastic is another good alternative to wood in areas with high humidity.  Plastic does not rot in moist, humid environments like wood does.

If temperatures are high, you will want to choose a lighter color of plastic.  That way, the plastic will not absorb so much heat from sunlight, and the soil will not get too hot and hurt your plants.

You Move Frequently

If you move your raised beds frequently, then making them out of a lighter plastic material will make things much easier.  If you move to a new home frequently, then you might be able to take plastic raised beds with you.

Wood

Wood is a less durable material than stone, and it is susceptible to rot, unlike plastic.  So, why use wood at all?

Well, wood is lighter than stone, and easier to work with.  You don’t need to use any cement to hold wood together – a few nails or screws will do it.

Some people also prefer the appearance of wood over stone, plastic, or metal, since it looks more natural in a garden.

I include lumbers, sticks, and logs in this category.  There are several advantages to using wood for your raised bed.

Pros of Wood

  • Wood is sturdy, yet easy to work with.  While not as tough as stone, wood will hold up well until it begins to rot (this may not happen for several years with more durable or treated wood).  It is also lighter than stone, making it less likely that you will injure yourself working with it.
  • Wood is common and widely available.  Whether you use sticks, logs, or lumber to build your raised bed, you will be able to find a source of wood easily.
  • Wood will eventually rot, meaning it is environmentally friendly (biodegradable).  If the wood is untreated, you can just use the old rotted wood as mulch, or add it to your compost pile, whenever you build a new raised bed.
  • There are many raised garden bed kits and plans that use wood, so you should have no trouble finding one that works for you.  For example, here is a wood raised garden bed kit from Etsy.

You can also cut wooden boards to size and create your own custom raised garden bed.

containerized raised bed
You can make a raised bed out of sticks, like this one. You can also make one out of logs. Either way, it will be biodegradable, but it might rot away sooner than you would like!

Cons of Wood

Although there are some redeeming qualities of wood, it also has some serious drawbacks.

  • Older wood may contain toxic chemicals.  Some types of wood are treated with chemicals that can leach into soil.  Your plants (including vegetables!) may later absorb these chemicals from the soil.  Old railroad ties are treated with creosote, which contains lots of nasty chemicals.  Older pressure-treated wood can also contain CCA (chromated copper arsenic), another nasty chemical.  This will be less of a problem as time goes on, but you will still need to source your wood carefully to avoid this.
  • Wood is susceptible to damage from exposure to soil, rain, and insects.  Wood will eventually rot, especially if it comes in direct contact with wet soil.  It may also attract insects that want to feed on the wood or live in it (termites or carpenter ants).

When to Use Wood

Wood is a good choice for building a raised bed in the following situations:

You Want a Biodegradable Raised Bed

Rotting wood may not be a problem if you want a temporary structure.  When untreated wood rots, you can use the remains as mulch or as part of your compost pile.

You can then build new raised beds out of wood in a new location.  This might be helpful if you like to experiment with growing in different locations in your garden.

Here are some types of wood you can use, in order from least to most rot-resistant:

  • Pine – a softer wood that is often used for furniture, but not as useful for outdoor projects.  Pine does not hold up well when exposed to soil, water, and insects.  This wood will rot within a few years of exposure to the elements.
  • Oak – a hard wood that is more difficult to work with than pine.  Oak boards will last longer than pine when used to build a raised bed.
  • Cypress – a soft wood that nonetheless holds up fairly well against rot when in contact with wet soil.  Cypress has naturals oil that acts as preservatives, allowing it to resist damage from decay and insects.
  • Cedar – a soft wood that holds up very well against rot in outdoor conditions.  Like cypress, it contains natural oils that help to preserve it and protect against rot and insects.  However, its appearance will naturally fade over time before it eventually rots.  Cedar is more expensive than other wood.
  • Redwood – a soft wood that lasts quite a long time, even in outdoor conditions when exposed to wet soil and insects.  Redwood is very expensive, but it can last up to 30 years.

This article from the University of Georgia has more information on cedar, cypress, pine and other building materials for raised beds.

You Have Leftover Wood from another Project

If you have leftover wood from another project, you can use it to build a raised bed instead of throwing it away.  You can also harvest wood from a demolition project if it is still in good shape.

However, you will need to make sure that the wood is safe to use for gardening before you build!  Lots of older wood is treated with chemicals that you don’t want anywhere near your vegetable garden.

For example:

  • Railroad ties are treated with creosote, which can have lots of nasty chemicals in it.
  • Old pressure-treated may be treated with CCA (chromated copper arsenate), a preservative that uses copper as a fungicide.  Sun and rain can cause arsenic to leach out of wood treated with CCA, so avoid using it for raised beds or other outdoor construction projects in your yard!

You can find more information about creosote and CCA in this article from the Iowa State University Extension.

Wood Treatments

There are a few ways to treat wood to protect it against the elements and prevent rotting.

One way is to use an oil-based stain on the wood.  Go with a newer product – if you have old wood stain from decades ago lying around, it could contain harmful chemicals that are just as bad as creosote or CCA.

You can also use exterior latex paint to seal wood against damage from water, soil, and insects.  Use a lighter color if you want the wood (and soil) to absorb less heat.  Use a darker color to keep the soil in the raised bed warmer.

Another option to protect a wooden raised bed from the elements is to use a raised bed liner.  The most common ones are made of waterproof plastic, which will keep the wood dry and slow down rotting.

You can use these waterproof liners on both the inside and outside of the raised bed to protect both sides of the wood from rotting.

There are pros and cons to using a plastic raised bed liner, but I think they are worth it overall.  I wrote an article all about raised bed liners, so you can learn more about them here.

Metal

Metal is a tough material, and it won’t rot.  However, it can be difficult to work with, and it will rust unless treated.  Here are some pros of using metal for your raised bed:

Pros of Metal

  • Metal is strong, and will be able to hold lots of wet soil without buckling under the weight.  Plastic (and even some types of wood) will not hold up so well against all that weight.
  • You can use a metal stock tank (from an animal feed/grain store) as a ready-made raised bed.
  • You may be able to source sheets of scrap metal for free or cheap from a junkyard or junk dealer, thus reducing your cost of building your own raised bed.
  • You can put a metal sheet against an existing chain link fence to give you one of the sides for a raised bed.  The metal sheet will prevent soil from falling through the chain link fence, while the fence will give you one wall for “free”.  You can then build the rest of the raised bed out of whatever you want.
metal stock tank
A metal stock tank can be used as a raised garden bed – this one might be too tall though!

Cons of Metal

Although there are some benefits of using metal for raised beds, there are drawbacks to consider as well.

  • Metal will heat up quickly in the sun, possibly warming the soil too much on hot, sunny days.
  • Iron or steel will eventually rust, unless treated.
  • Metal can be a hazard to children or pets, due to sharp edges, rust, or hot metal.

When to Use Metal

If you want something lighter than stone, stronger than plastic, and rot-resistant, then metal is your best option.  However, if you need to keep your yard “kid-safe” or “pet-safe”, then building a raised bed out of metal is not a good idea.

Materials to Avoid Using for Raised Garden Beds

When building a raised bed or gardening container, avoid anything that could leach harmful chemicals into your soil.  This includes some of the items mentioned earlier, including:

  • Railroad ties (due to creosote)
  • Old pallets and pressure treated lumber (due to CCA)
  • Old tires

Even if you are not growing vegetables, it is still a good idea to avoid these materials for raised beds or gardening.  Pollinators, such as bees, will visit the flowers of these plants, and they could be exposed to the harmful chemicals.

Alternatives to Raised Garden Beds

If you don’t want to build a raised garden bed, there are some alternatives to consider:

  • Straw Bales – you can set up a long, narrow row of straw bales and use them for growing your vegetables.  For example, you can grow potatoes in straw bales.
  • Grow Bags – you can also use grow bags for vegetables or flowers.  You can even use larger grow bags for dwarf fruit trees.  If you put a group of grow bags together in a row, you can create a “raised bed” without going to the trouble of constructing one.  You can move them during the season to take advantage of sun or shade in your yard.  You can learn more about the pros & cons of grow bags here.
  • Soil Mounds – this is the most basic type of raised bed ever!  You don’t need to construct anything, use any nails, lay down any straw, or buy any grow bags!  All you need do is mound up some soil and grow your plants right on top of the mound!  Potatoes, sweet potatoes, and other vegetables are well-suited to mounding, so it’s something to consider.
straw bales
You can use straw bales as part of your raised beds. You can grow potatoes and other crops in straw!

Conclusion

Now you know the pros and cons of the materials you can use for building raised garden beds.  Hopefully, you will have an easier time deciding which material is best for your garden.

I hope you found this article helpful – if so, please share it with someone who will find the information useful.  It’s time to start building your raised bed and make it last!

jonathon.david.madore

Hi, I'm Jon. Let's solve your gardening problems, spend more time growing, and get the best harvest every year!

Recent Content